My last post was about Bainbridge and how the man and the ships named after him formed an eerie connection between past and present. It seems that the Bainbridge connection isn't the only one, though it took me a while to see this one for what it was.
Captain Sterett was deployed in command of the USS Enterprize (the first US warship to be named so) and tasked with finding and eliminating Barbary pirates. Posing as a British ship, Sterett encountered a pirate ship, the Tripoli. The captain of the Tripoli lamented to Sterett that he had yet to see an American ship to harass.
Sterett then revealed the true identity of his ship and a three hour battle ensued. At the end of the battle, the Tripoli surrendered and lost a crippling portion of its crew. The Enterprize, however, suffered only minor damage and none of the crew had been seriously injured.
The first interaction between the US Navy and the Barbary pirates had gone remarkably well for the US. Congress was so pleased with Sterett that they commissioned a sword for the captain and the President, Thomas Jefferson, presented it to him in person.
Fast forward to 2011. Roughly two years after the rescue of Captain Philips of the Maersk Alabama, another group of Americans are in the hands of the Somali pirates. American warships again race to the scene and again, the Navy SEALs are on-site to conduct a rescue.
Regrettably, the precedent set by the Maersk Alabama caused the Somali pirates to kill the four Americans held hostage before they could be rescued. Two pirates died in the subsequent boarding undertaken by the SEALs with another 13-15 taken prisoner.
For Somali pirates to kill their main source of ransom is unusual and evidently spurred on by the Alabama incident. But it gets even more unusual than that. Before the execution of the hostages, the Somali pirates fired at a warship 600 yards away with an RPG and small arms fire.
The name of the warship?
The USS Sterett. And just like in the past, the ship sustained no damage or injuries in the exchange of fire.
Another interesting fact is that one of the four ships involved in the response was the aircraft carrier USS Enterprise.
Exploration of Human Security
This blog has been set up as part of a continuing effort to construct a meaningful discussion of early American history, contemporary policy, and the concept of human security and its relationship with national security. The two primary objects of focus are and have been the Barbary pirates of the 19th century and the Somali pirates of the 21st century but other topics will be discussed as well.
Barbary War
Sailors fending off a pirate attack.
Sunday, June 23, 2013
Saturday, June 22, 2013
A Quirk of History
One of the things that really drew me to the story of the Barbary Wars is a peculiar coincidence.
Captain William Bainbridge was in command of the USS Philadelphia when it ran aground off the coast of Tripoli in 1803. He had been pursuing a ship that was attempting to break the blockade enforced by a squadron of American warships.
Bainbridge soon elected to surrender the ship but not before doing his utmost to sink the ship to prevent it from falling into enemy hands. Sadly for Bainbridge, the Philadelphia was not beyond repair and the Tripolitans were able to salvage the vessel. Bainbridge could see his former ship floating placidly in the harbor from captivity and to make things worse, the ruler of Tripoli had renamed the ship "Gift of Allah".
This setback was one of many for poor Bainbridge. His ship had been the only warship lost to the French during the Quasi-War (the first to be surrendered in the history of the US Navy) and he had been in command when the Dey of Algiers commandeered the George Washington in 1800. The Dey demanded that the ship be used to transport tribute and other goods to Constantinople (Istanbul). When Bainbridge refused, the American flag was hauled down and replaced by the Algierian flag and the George Washington went anyway. It was a tremendous humiliation for the United States.
Bainbridge eventually was released and he cleared his name of any wrongdoing; eventually demonstrating superb leadership and heroism in the service of his country.
Fast forward to the capture of the Maersk Alabama in 2009. An American captain, Captain Philips was held hostage by four Somali pirates in a lifeboat belonging to the cargo ship. Navy SEALs were flown out to the American warship that responded to the distress call and after a tense standoff, the SEAL snipers killed the three remaining pirates in the lifeboat. And the name of the American warship that they shot off of?
You guessed it, the USS Bainbridge.
Captain William Bainbridge was in command of the USS Philadelphia when it ran aground off the coast of Tripoli in 1803. He had been pursuing a ship that was attempting to break the blockade enforced by a squadron of American warships.
Bainbridge soon elected to surrender the ship but not before doing his utmost to sink the ship to prevent it from falling into enemy hands. Sadly for Bainbridge, the Philadelphia was not beyond repair and the Tripolitans were able to salvage the vessel. Bainbridge could see his former ship floating placidly in the harbor from captivity and to make things worse, the ruler of Tripoli had renamed the ship "Gift of Allah".
This setback was one of many for poor Bainbridge. His ship had been the only warship lost to the French during the Quasi-War (the first to be surrendered in the history of the US Navy) and he had been in command when the Dey of Algiers commandeered the George Washington in 1800. The Dey demanded that the ship be used to transport tribute and other goods to Constantinople (Istanbul). When Bainbridge refused, the American flag was hauled down and replaced by the Algierian flag and the George Washington went anyway. It was a tremendous humiliation for the United States.
Bainbridge eventually was released and he cleared his name of any wrongdoing; eventually demonstrating superb leadership and heroism in the service of his country.
Fast forward to the capture of the Maersk Alabama in 2009. An American captain, Captain Philips was held hostage by four Somali pirates in a lifeboat belonging to the cargo ship. Navy SEALs were flown out to the American warship that responded to the distress call and after a tense standoff, the SEAL snipers killed the three remaining pirates in the lifeboat. And the name of the American warship that they shot off of?
You guessed it, the USS Bainbridge.
Saturday, June 8, 2013
Is military force the answer?
I can't possibly hope to answer such a complicated question in a short blog post but it is worth having a short discussion.
The Somali piracy issue is a thorny one, with many factors conspiring to make it a problem that resists simplistic solutions. It isn't as cut and dry as the Barbary problem, where a show of force and cash was enough to ease things along.
So is it appropriate to use military force? The Navy SEALs have been employed in three rescue efforts, with two of them being successful; the Maersk Alabama, the rescue of humanitarian aid workers held hostage by pirates, and the unsuccessful rescue of four Americans held captive on their yacht the Quest.
The use of warships to patrol a designated "safe corridor" is also paying dividends. The success rate of piracy has dramatically decreased since 2011. The benefits of having warships in the region was demonstrated again yesterday when a Somali attack was foiled by European ships.
According to the Christian Science Monitor, however, it is not clear what is responsible for the decline. Some shipping companies are hiring private security firms to man the ships with armed security teams and international organizations have released suggestions on how to avoid pirate attacks.
As a last note, I find it interesting that the CSM article describes how the Barbary pirates were captured and killed by the United States. In reality, the US sought to blockade the port of Tripoli and conducted a minor invasion of Derna. Those actions were enough to bring the ruler of Tripoli to the table for diplomatic solutions.
To give you an idea of the type of operations conducted in the first Barbary War, I'll share the story of Captain Sterret.
Sterret was on cruise against the Tripolitans, ordered to protect American shipping from attacks. Upon encountering a pirate vessel, he attacked and a battle that lasted three hours began. The pirates lowered their flag three times in surrender and when the Americans moved in to capture the ship, the flag was raised and the fighting began again. After the third time this happened, Sterret ordered that the ship was to be sunk instead of taken for a prize.
One account relays that the Tripolitans threw their flag overboard the last time they surrendered, to demonstrate their sincerity. Once the pirates had given up, it is reasonable to assume that they were executed on the spot or sent to the US for trial. None of those things happened.
Because the United States had not officially declared war on Tripoli, the pirates who had surrendered were protected and their ship could not be sunk. Instead, the American sailors threw all war materiel overboard, put the remaining pirates back on their ship, and had them sail home.
While Sterret was hailed as a hero (he had lost no men in the fight and his ship sustained minor damage), the nation criticized Jefferson for his orders, which led to the release of the pirate ship. Alexander Hamilton claimed that the turn of events proved that Jefferson lacked the necessary fortitude and aggression that a strong Commander-in-Chief required. Jefferson, for his part, was simply adhering to the Constitution by issuing orders which reflected the fact that Congress had not declared war. With that fact, any act of war was clearly unauthorized and thus could not be ordered by the President.
Such a gross oversimplification of the Barbary problem and solution indicates to me that it is worth digging into the history and giving a clear picture of what happened. Historical solutions to modern problems work only if the history is understood in its context.
The Somali piracy issue is a thorny one, with many factors conspiring to make it a problem that resists simplistic solutions. It isn't as cut and dry as the Barbary problem, where a show of force and cash was enough to ease things along.
So is it appropriate to use military force? The Navy SEALs have been employed in three rescue efforts, with two of them being successful; the Maersk Alabama, the rescue of humanitarian aid workers held hostage by pirates, and the unsuccessful rescue of four Americans held captive on their yacht the Quest.
The use of warships to patrol a designated "safe corridor" is also paying dividends. The success rate of piracy has dramatically decreased since 2011. The benefits of having warships in the region was demonstrated again yesterday when a Somali attack was foiled by European ships.
According to the Christian Science Monitor, however, it is not clear what is responsible for the decline. Some shipping companies are hiring private security firms to man the ships with armed security teams and international organizations have released suggestions on how to avoid pirate attacks.
As a last note, I find it interesting that the CSM article describes how the Barbary pirates were captured and killed by the United States. In reality, the US sought to blockade the port of Tripoli and conducted a minor invasion of Derna. Those actions were enough to bring the ruler of Tripoli to the table for diplomatic solutions.
To give you an idea of the type of operations conducted in the first Barbary War, I'll share the story of Captain Sterret.
Sterret was on cruise against the Tripolitans, ordered to protect American shipping from attacks. Upon encountering a pirate vessel, he attacked and a battle that lasted three hours began. The pirates lowered their flag three times in surrender and when the Americans moved in to capture the ship, the flag was raised and the fighting began again. After the third time this happened, Sterret ordered that the ship was to be sunk instead of taken for a prize.
One account relays that the Tripolitans threw their flag overboard the last time they surrendered, to demonstrate their sincerity. Once the pirates had given up, it is reasonable to assume that they were executed on the spot or sent to the US for trial. None of those things happened.
Because the United States had not officially declared war on Tripoli, the pirates who had surrendered were protected and their ship could not be sunk. Instead, the American sailors threw all war materiel overboard, put the remaining pirates back on their ship, and had them sail home.
While Sterret was hailed as a hero (he had lost no men in the fight and his ship sustained minor damage), the nation criticized Jefferson for his orders, which led to the release of the pirate ship. Alexander Hamilton claimed that the turn of events proved that Jefferson lacked the necessary fortitude and aggression that a strong Commander-in-Chief required. Jefferson, for his part, was simply adhering to the Constitution by issuing orders which reflected the fact that Congress had not declared war. With that fact, any act of war was clearly unauthorized and thus could not be ordered by the President.
Such a gross oversimplification of the Barbary problem and solution indicates to me that it is worth digging into the history and giving a clear picture of what happened. Historical solutions to modern problems work only if the history is understood in its context.
Thursday, June 6, 2013
Your math teacher could be right.
I remember sitting through math class hating the fact of how precise you had to be, regardless of how many digits or operations were required to find an answer. Keeping track of word problems always gave me the most difficulty.
D=RT, or Dirt equations were a nightmare and I would often, to my dismay, see that instead of correctly predicting a train's arrival in Chicago, I had calculated the equivalent of a trip into upper Canada.
I eventually learned how to properly do word problems but I definitely remember grumbling to myself that I would never have to worry about doing calculations like that. Certainly there were people, who knew far more than I ever did, that would create schedules or useful charts that I could use.
As it turns out, the people who do know far more than I do also occasionally struggle with word problems and the unfortunate results are blatantly obvious. Here's a version of the word problem:
The Spanish government wants to build a submarine. The submarine must be positively buoyant, which means that it has a natural tendency to float on its own. Buoyancy is primarily affected by the weight of the submarine and through the principle of displacement, the weight must be spread over a certain surface area so that the submarine can float.
The equation should generally look like this:
Length of the hull x the width (beam) x the draught (lowest point underwater to the waterline) and then divide by 35.
The actual math is obviously far more complicated than that and mistakes are easy to make:
Spanish government contracts US submarine builder to help fix a submarine design that may be too heavy to float.
It's interesting to me that one government would so willingly hand over a brand new submarine to another country even when facing such an enormous technical problem. I'm willing to bet that there is a lot of proprietary information that is now going to be seen literally first-hand.
Governments usually work very hard to prevent such an exchange of information. I wonder if the US would ever consider doing the same, if they were facing an issue where another country had the experts in place to help out.
D=RT, or Dirt equations were a nightmare and I would often, to my dismay, see that instead of correctly predicting a train's arrival in Chicago, I had calculated the equivalent of a trip into upper Canada.
I eventually learned how to properly do word problems but I definitely remember grumbling to myself that I would never have to worry about doing calculations like that. Certainly there were people, who knew far more than I ever did, that would create schedules or useful charts that I could use.
As it turns out, the people who do know far more than I do also occasionally struggle with word problems and the unfortunate results are blatantly obvious. Here's a version of the word problem:
The Spanish government wants to build a submarine. The submarine must be positively buoyant, which means that it has a natural tendency to float on its own. Buoyancy is primarily affected by the weight of the submarine and through the principle of displacement, the weight must be spread over a certain surface area so that the submarine can float.
The equation should generally look like this:
Length of the hull x the width (beam) x the draught (lowest point underwater to the waterline) and then divide by 35.
The actual math is obviously far more complicated than that and mistakes are easy to make:
Spanish government contracts US submarine builder to help fix a submarine design that may be too heavy to float.
It's interesting to me that one government would so willingly hand over a brand new submarine to another country even when facing such an enormous technical problem. I'm willing to bet that there is a lot of proprietary information that is now going to be seen literally first-hand.
Governments usually work very hard to prevent such an exchange of information. I wonder if the US would ever consider doing the same, if they were facing an issue where another country had the experts in place to help out.
Tuesday, June 4, 2013
Hostis Humanis Generis
For centuries, pirates have been considered to be a special breed of criminals. Since they operated in international waters and were equal opportunity predators when it came to international shipping, the Latin phrase "Hostis Humanis Generis" has been applied to them.
The phrase translates to "threats to mankind" which means that any nation which captures them can deal with them in any way they like. The most common punishment was death to serve as a warning to other pirates or to other sailors who may be considering a life of parrots and plunder.
As I've been reading lately, one of the largest hurdles in dealing with modern pirates is the fact that there aren't many nations that are willing to tackle the legal issues surrounding these criminals. No one is really sure how to prosecute those accused, or who should take the responsibility for doing so. For the most part, the system has been termed "catch and release" where suspected or confirmed pirates have been returned to their country of origin with little or no penalty. At the time of one writing, the US has been turning over their pirate suspects to the courts in Nigeria which is also suffering from an upswing in pirate incidents.
Apparently, that trend may be changing, but not as an effort to curtail piracy itself. Somali pirates that have been transported to Virginia are facing the death penalty for their role in the death of four Americans that had been taken captive on their yacht. When the Navy moved in to prevent the pirates from returning to Somalia, gunfire erupted, which led to the deaths of the four Americans and four of the pirates.
Here's a link to a relevant article: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/somali-pirates-will-face-death-penalty-in-federal-trial-in-va/2013/06/02/197a8868-c969-11e2-8da7-d274bc611a47_story.html
It's clear that we can't return to the days of old where pirates were hung in gibbets or gallows just outside of ports for all to see. It is also clear, however, that we need to figure out a legal system that is capable of navigating the complex intricacies of international justice as a way to prosecute the pirates.
The phrase translates to "threats to mankind" which means that any nation which captures them can deal with them in any way they like. The most common punishment was death to serve as a warning to other pirates or to other sailors who may be considering a life of parrots and plunder.
As I've been reading lately, one of the largest hurdles in dealing with modern pirates is the fact that there aren't many nations that are willing to tackle the legal issues surrounding these criminals. No one is really sure how to prosecute those accused, or who should take the responsibility for doing so. For the most part, the system has been termed "catch and release" where suspected or confirmed pirates have been returned to their country of origin with little or no penalty. At the time of one writing, the US has been turning over their pirate suspects to the courts in Nigeria which is also suffering from an upswing in pirate incidents.
Apparently, that trend may be changing, but not as an effort to curtail piracy itself. Somali pirates that have been transported to Virginia are facing the death penalty for their role in the death of four Americans that had been taken captive on their yacht. When the Navy moved in to prevent the pirates from returning to Somalia, gunfire erupted, which led to the deaths of the four Americans and four of the pirates.
Here's a link to a relevant article: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/somali-pirates-will-face-death-penalty-in-federal-trial-in-va/2013/06/02/197a8868-c969-11e2-8da7-d274bc611a47_story.html
It's clear that we can't return to the days of old where pirates were hung in gibbets or gallows just outside of ports for all to see. It is also clear, however, that we need to figure out a legal system that is capable of navigating the complex intricacies of international justice as a way to prosecute the pirates.
Monday, June 3, 2013
What you can do with pirates?
There are many things you can do with pirates:
Studying the Barbary Wars and related topics revealed something very illuminating for me: the grey areas surrounding the use (and potential for abuse) of military power by the Executive Branch is a function of the original documents that define our government. In other words, while some of the blame does lie at the feet of those individuals who exploit the system for their own agendas, the system itself has always been flawed in this manner. From the outset, this flaw, ambiguity, loophole, whatever you want to call it, has been present.
We have to remember that our Constitution came out of a successful revolution but also from a failed experiment of a federation of states. Our Founders were making things up as they went in an effort to create a better system. They doing the best they could and have obviously done pretty well but there is a limit to anyone's foresight and wisdom.
- Cruise the Spanish Main.
- Drink rum.
- Download the latest album or movie.
- Attend or hold speech therapy classes to correct a tragic over-emphasis on "R's".
- Hang them outside of harbors as a warning to other disgruntled sailors.
- Sail the seven seas.
- Apparently pirates can also be employed to fight ninjas:
- How and why piracy emerges i.e. as a result of a government that cannot effectively patrol it's borders, interior, or enforce its laws, as well as economic factors.
- The impact of piracy on the world, economically, politically, and militarily.
- What piracy means for national, global, and human security.
- The foundation of the United States government: piracy is explicitly mentioned in the Constitution---look it up! (Hint: Article 1)---and the Barbary pirates created a national debate on whether or not to create a military---an organization that is problematic for the republic originally envisioned by some of our Founders.
- Division of power in the American government, or the powers of each branch as they are enumerated in the Constitution.
Studying the Barbary Wars and related topics revealed something very illuminating for me: the grey areas surrounding the use (and potential for abuse) of military power by the Executive Branch is a function of the original documents that define our government. In other words, while some of the blame does lie at the feet of those individuals who exploit the system for their own agendas, the system itself has always been flawed in this manner. From the outset, this flaw, ambiguity, loophole, whatever you want to call it, has been present.
We have to remember that our Constitution came out of a successful revolution but also from a failed experiment of a federation of states. Our Founders were making things up as they went in an effort to create a better system. They doing the best they could and have obviously done pretty well but there is a limit to anyone's foresight and wisdom.
Friday, May 31, 2013
The AUMF Effect.
Every now and then I try to catch up on episodes of the Colbert Report and the Daily Show that I missed for whatever reason. The May 23rd episode revealed a pleasant surprise in the form of a huge link to American history.
Recently, President Obama gave a speech at the National Defense University and included a few words about a Joint Resolution passed by Congress regarding the prosecution of terrorists. The legal document came out of the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, titled the Authorization of the Use of Military Force (AUMF). With the resolution, Congress bestowed significant power upon the President as Commander-in-Chief, effectively giving the President a blank but signed check when it comes to the application of military power. Here is Colbert's take on the matter:
http://media.mtvnservices.com/mgid:cms:video:colbertnation.com:426698
Yet this sort of thing is nothing new. Some people might think back to the Gulf of Tokin Resolution (which drew us further into Vietnam) as a prime example, but there is one that appears even earlier in our history.
In 1802, Congress passed the Act for the Protection of the Commerce and Seamen of the United States, Against the Tripolitan Cruisers. The full text is here in the link. As a quick note of explanation, Congress never actually declared war on Tripoli and my preferred link to the Yale Avalon project is not currently working. The content in the center of the hot pink background is legit though, so no worries on that end.
President Jefferson deployed a squadron of American warships to the Mediterranean, to act as protection for American shipping against pirate attacks. As Commander-in-Chief, he was well within his rights to do so but he also acknowledged the role and power of Congress. In a speech to Congress informing them of his action, he also made it clear that it was only they who could choose to go to war with Tripoli. Congress never did declare war but they did pass a Resolution that basically gave Jefferson a blank check and the explicit permission of Congress to utilize any means necessary to counter the threat. In other words, Jefferson received an AUMF that is very similar in spirit to the very same given to President Bush and his successor, President Obama.
Recently, President Obama gave a speech at the National Defense University and included a few words about a Joint Resolution passed by Congress regarding the prosecution of terrorists. The legal document came out of the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, titled the Authorization of the Use of Military Force (AUMF). With the resolution, Congress bestowed significant power upon the President as Commander-in-Chief, effectively giving the President a blank but signed check when it comes to the application of military power. Here is Colbert's take on the matter:
http://media.mtvnservices.com/mgid:cms:video:colbertnation.com:426698
Yet this sort of thing is nothing new. Some people might think back to the Gulf of Tokin Resolution (which drew us further into Vietnam) as a prime example, but there is one that appears even earlier in our history.
In 1802, Congress passed the Act for the Protection of the Commerce and Seamen of the United States, Against the Tripolitan Cruisers. The full text is here in the link. As a quick note of explanation, Congress never actually declared war on Tripoli and my preferred link to the Yale Avalon project is not currently working. The content in the center of the hot pink background is legit though, so no worries on that end.
President Jefferson deployed a squadron of American warships to the Mediterranean, to act as protection for American shipping against pirate attacks. As Commander-in-Chief, he was well within his rights to do so but he also acknowledged the role and power of Congress. In a speech to Congress informing them of his action, he also made it clear that it was only they who could choose to go to war with Tripoli. Congress never did declare war but they did pass a Resolution that basically gave Jefferson a blank check and the explicit permission of Congress to utilize any means necessary to counter the threat. In other words, Jefferson received an AUMF that is very similar in spirit to the very same given to President Bush and his successor, President Obama.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
