I can't possibly hope to answer such a complicated question in a short blog post but it is worth having a short discussion.
The Somali piracy issue is a thorny one, with many factors conspiring to make it a problem that resists simplistic solutions. It isn't as cut and dry as the Barbary problem, where a show of force and cash was enough to ease things along.
So is it appropriate to use military force? The Navy SEALs have been employed in three rescue efforts, with two of them being successful; the Maersk Alabama, the rescue of humanitarian aid workers held hostage by pirates, and the unsuccessful rescue of four Americans held captive on their yacht the Quest.
The use of warships to patrol a designated "safe corridor" is also paying dividends. The success rate of piracy has dramatically decreased since 2011. The benefits of having warships in the region was demonstrated again yesterday when a Somali attack was foiled by European ships.
According to the Christian Science Monitor, however, it is not clear what is responsible for the decline. Some shipping companies are hiring private security firms to man the ships with armed security teams and international organizations have released suggestions on how to avoid pirate attacks.
As a last note, I find it interesting that the CSM article describes how the Barbary pirates were captured and killed by the United States. In reality, the US sought to blockade the port of Tripoli and conducted a minor invasion of Derna. Those actions were enough to bring the ruler of Tripoli to the table for diplomatic solutions.
To give you an idea of the type of operations conducted in the first Barbary War, I'll share the story of Captain Sterret.
Sterret was on cruise against the Tripolitans, ordered to protect American shipping from attacks. Upon encountering a pirate vessel, he attacked and a battle that lasted three hours began. The pirates lowered their flag three times in surrender and when the Americans moved in to capture the ship, the flag was raised and the fighting began again. After the third time this happened, Sterret ordered that the ship was to be sunk instead of taken for a prize.
One account relays that the Tripolitans threw their flag overboard the last time they surrendered, to demonstrate their sincerity. Once the pirates had given up, it is reasonable to assume that they were executed on the spot or sent to the US for trial. None of those things happened.
Because the United States had not officially declared war on Tripoli, the pirates who had surrendered were protected and their ship could not be sunk. Instead, the American sailors threw all war materiel overboard, put the remaining pirates back on their ship, and had them sail home.
While Sterret was hailed as a hero (he had lost no men in the fight and his ship sustained minor damage), the nation criticized Jefferson for his orders, which led to the release of the pirate ship. Alexander Hamilton claimed that the turn of events proved that Jefferson lacked the necessary fortitude and aggression that a strong Commander-in-Chief required. Jefferson, for his part, was simply adhering to the Constitution by issuing orders which reflected the fact that Congress had not declared war. With that fact, any act of war was clearly unauthorized and thus could not be ordered by the President.
Such a gross oversimplification of the Barbary problem and solution indicates to me that it is worth digging into the history and giving a clear picture of what happened. Historical solutions to modern problems work only if the history is understood in its context.
No comments:
Post a Comment