Barbary War

Barbary War
Sailors fending off a pirate attack.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Hostis Humanis Generis

For centuries, pirates have been considered to be a special breed of criminals.  Since they operated in international waters and were equal opportunity predators when it came to international shipping, the Latin phrase "Hostis Humanis Generis" has been applied to them.  

The phrase translates to "threats to mankind" which means that any nation which captures them can deal with them in any way they like.  The most common punishment was death to serve as a warning to other pirates or to other sailors who may be considering a life of parrots and plunder.

As I've been reading lately, one of the largest hurdles in dealing with modern pirates is the fact that there aren't many nations that are willing to tackle the legal issues surrounding these criminals.  No one is really sure how to prosecute those accused, or who should take the responsibility for doing so.  For the most part, the system has been termed "catch and release" where suspected or confirmed pirates have been returned to their country of origin with little or no penalty.  At the time of one writing, the US has been turning over their pirate suspects to the courts in Nigeria which is also suffering from an upswing in pirate incidents.

Apparently, that trend may be changing, but not as an effort to curtail piracy itself.  Somali pirates that have been transported to Virginia are facing the death penalty for their role in the death of four Americans that had been taken captive on their yacht.  When the Navy moved in to prevent the pirates from returning to Somalia, gunfire erupted, which led to the deaths of the four Americans and four of the pirates.

Here's a link to a relevant article: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/somali-pirates-will-face-death-penalty-in-federal-trial-in-va/2013/06/02/197a8868-c969-11e2-8da7-d274bc611a47_story.html

It's clear that we can't return to the days of old where pirates were hung in gibbets or gallows just outside of ports for all to see.  It is also clear, however, that we need to figure out a legal system that is capable of navigating the complex intricacies of international justice as a way to prosecute the pirates.
  

No comments: